This is what Pa. can do to rally investors around its new pay for success projects - Generocity Philly


Jun. 1, 2016 3:03 pm

This is what Pa. can do to rally investors around its new pay for success projects

The state is launching twin projects to lower recidivism rates, and partners are expecting capital to flow in from investors. Here's how they can make sure that happens.

How do you measure success in the social sector?

(Photo by Flickr user Håvar og Solveig, used under a Creative Commons license)

Last month, we broke the news that Pennsylvania would become one of a handful of U.S. states to launch pay for success (PFS) projects (and the only one to launch two simultaneously).

The twin projects will aim to reduce recidivism rates across the state by scaling programs offered by nonprofits Center for Employment Opportunities and Youth Advocate Programs.

PFS is an innovative, unproven and complicated funding strategy designed to tackle public sector problems like recidivism by employing private sector solutions — and private sector capital.

That’s what makes it exciting. The strategy is ultimately structured to save taxpayers and their governments money not only by cutting spending on things like incarceration, but by shifting the financial risk to investors like foundations, financial institutions and venture capitalists.

But private sector investors want measurable outcomes. Quantifying social impact, conversely, is an unproven science. Therein lies the rub.  Not knowing exactly what the results of your investment is not particularly appealing for venture capitalists and financial institutions, and it’s why traditionally risk-averse foundations have played vital roles in PFS deals to date.

“We run into issues with government about being really crystal clear and specific about which outcomes they’re trying to achieve,” said Jeff Shumway, VP of advisory services at Social Finance, the nonprofit tapped to broker Pennsylvania’s PFS projects.

Pennsylvania’s pay for success projects, like those before it, will have a hard time luring private capital without a shared understanding of what “success” entails.

“How can an investor, with no formal training in social science, be in a position to interpret fairly dense academic literature and make a judgment about the likelihood of success for a particular intervention?” writes Mission Measurement CEO and social sector data scientist Jason Saul in a Huffington Post essay.

From our Partners

“They can’t.”

Read the full story

Those who are familiar with PFS funding and structure like Philanthropy Network Executive Director Maari Porter and former Michael Nutter Policy Director Maia Jachimowicz have said securing funding is typically the easiest part of the PFS equation — especially from foundations.

But what about private capital? In his post, Saul proposed three ideas to remove some of the risk that has kept many private investors away from PFS, but one rings true for Pennsylvania: “Success” needs to be defined and standardized, ideally by an independent evaluator.

“But the only way that [PFS] or any form of social finance can attract true risk-capital is if investors are able to pre-determine the likelihood of success for an investment,” he writes.


From our Partners

The Enterprise Center’s $1M initiative aims to transform Black and brown cleaning businesses into certified disinfectors

Predictions for nonprofits 2021

Money moves: Wells Fargo regional foundations transfer $100M in charitable assets to Philadelphia Foundation


Generocity Philly

Inscripción Doble en Congreso: Lo que trae el futuro


Pennsylvania Prison Society

Major Gifts and Development Manager (P/T)

Apply Now
3217 W. Clearfield St. Phila, PA 19132

St. James School

Workforce Development Coordinator

Apply Now
3217 W. Clearfield St. Phila, PA 19132

St. James School

Graduate Support Fellow – Servant Year

Apply Now

Philly Forward Forum features speakers who aim to disrupt poverty, dismantle racism and kickstart upward mobility

Hindsight Is 2020: The year everything we should have known became obvious

Facing a cliff: Is this the end of pandemic support and relief?


Generocity Philly

Dual Enrollment at Congreso: Where does it go from here?

3217 W. Clearfield St. Phila, PA 19132

St. James School

Graduate Support Success Specialist

Apply Now
Harrisburg, PA

Public Health Management Corporation

Regional Manager, Healthcare and Emergency Management (NW and Central Pa.)

Apply Now
Philadelphia PA

Fairmount Park Conservancy


Apply Now

Sign-up for daily news updates from Generocity