That recidivism technology Philadelphia is getting might not account for racist policing - Generocity Philly

Results

Sep. 19, 2016 9:07 am

That recidivism technology Philadelphia is getting might not account for racist policing

If it does, said Councilman Curtis Jones, Jr. at a recent City Council hearing, it will "lose some accuracy." What do local advocates think? Technical.ly Philly reports.

Penn statistician Richard Berk.

(Photo by Juliana Reyes)

It turns out Philadelphia’s potentially racist recidivism algorithm will “lose some accuracy” if it isn’t designed to be, well, a racist recidivism algorithm.

Funded by the $3.5 million MacArthur grant and developed by Penn statistician Richard Berk, the fairness and accuracy of the pending computer algorithm — being built to predict the probability of recidivism after arrest — was the subject of a recent City Council hearing.

There, REDEEMED founder and criminal justice reform advocate Bill Cobb asked Berk if the technology will account for what Technical.ly Philly described as a “legacy of racist policing and policies” (a legacy that includes significantly higher rates of arrest, incarceration and unemployment among Black and Brown men than any other population).

“If we strive for fairness, unfortunately, we’re going to lose some accuracy,”said Berk. “That’s a price. It’s a price you may choose to pay.”

Read the full story

According to Technical.ly, Berk removed himself from the ethics and morality of the algorithm despite questioning from reform advocates like Cobb and Defender Association chief Keir Bradford-Gray, the latter of whom reminded everyone how criminal justice is fundamentally supposed to be fair and unbiased.

“We tend to deal with things on the backend” when it comes to reforming the criminal justice system, Bradford-Gray told us recently, rather than work to “limit who’s coming into the criminal justice system” in the first place.

From our Partners

In other words, even if the algorithm is built to consider things like the lasting trauma of childhood poverty, it will not truly break the cycle of recidivism until it can prevent that traumatized child’s potential trajectory into the criminal justice system.

-30-
LEAVE A COMMENT

From our Partners

Rethinking disciplinary power in shelter

Kneel, donate, or burn it all down? Decarceration and 5 types of justice work

Nan Feyler is the new executive director of the PA Innocence Project

SPONSORED

Generocity Philly

Systems blocking people from self-sufficiency

Philadelphia

Fairmount Ventures Inc

Research Assistant (Part time)

Apply Now
Philadelphia

Fairmount Ventures Inc

Project Manager – Consultant

Apply Now

How PHMC enables employees to turn their passion into purpose

In their own words: The filmmakers of Hidden Lives Illuminated talk about prison and their art

Become a Generocity member for a chance to win a free ticket to #TechForwardConf

SPONSORED

Generocity Philly

JEVS+SNHU partnership is creating affordable, flexible degree programs for Philly

Philadelphia, PA

SteegeThomson Communications

Junior Associate

Apply Now
Philadelphia, PA

Community Legal Services, Inc

Homeownership & Consumer Rights Unit-Staff Attorney

Apply Now
Philadelphia, PA

Mental Health Partnerships

Director of Marketing & Development

Apply Now

Sign-up for daily news updates from Generocity