A look at the cuts Police School Diversion Program has made to student arrests - Generocity Philly


Nov. 2, 2016 7:35 am

A look at the cuts Police School Diversion Program has made to student arrests

News site TakePart profiles the police program and highlights the impact it has made in Philadelphia.

Law enforcement.

(Photo by Flickr user Jobs For Felons Hub, used under a Creative Commons license)

Philadelphia Police Department had a shining moment three years ago when they realized arresting high school kids already suffering from poverty-induced trauma was the wrong kind of intervention.

Eighty-seven percent of students in the Philadelphia School District qualify for a free or reduced-price lunch. In 2013, there were 1,600 in-school arrests made by police.

That year, when then-deputy commissioner Kevin Bethel began overseeing Philadelphia’s school police detail, he helped launch Police School Diversion Program in partnership with the school district and the Department of Human Services.

Bethel felt “taking a misbehaving student out of school in handcuffs was just another trauma,” reads an overview of the program’s impact in news site TakePart.

Read the full story

Here’s how the program has worked: Instead of making immediate arrests for things like disorderly conduct or possession of marijuana, officers talk to supervisors and witnesses and puts the student to the Diversion Intake Center. If it’s a first offense, students get a second chance.

In the 2015-2016 school year — one year after implementation — student arrests fell to 569. Only 13 percent of those students have messed up their second chance and been arrested. Compare that to recidivism rates among youth who spend time in placement, “which varies from 37 to 67 percent.”

The program aligns with what many local criminal justice reform advocates have been pushing for: If we truly want to reform the system for the future, we need to take a closer look at providing services to children suffering from trauma and limit police interventions.


From our Partners

Student-run advocacy nonprofit UrbEd is ‘reclaiming our school system’

ChickTech Philadelphia is bringing free tech education to local girls

Edtech orgs: Apply for this AT&T accelerator


Generocity Philly

For immigrants, civic engagement is essential to success

1330 N. 5th Street,Philadelphia, PA 19122


Brand Ambassador

Apply Now
Philadelphia, PA

Knight Foundation

Summer of 2018 Paid Internship at Knight Foundation

Apply Now
4355 Orchard Street, Philadelphia, PA 19124

Rebuilding Together Philadelphia

Development Director

Apply Now

A filmmaker made a movie about 4 North Philly kids’ lives. Five years later, she checked back in

Young people should be partners in the fight to end youth homelessness in Philly

PCCY is crowdfunding to keep kids cavity-free this spring break


Generocity Philly

This Philly Venezuelan wants to encourage ‘participation, not isolation’ among immigrants


William Penn Foundation

Program Associate, Creative Communities

Apply Now

Fairmount Ventures Inc

Project Manager

Apply Now
Center City Philadelphia

The Chamber of Commerce for Greater Philadelphia

Coordinator, Member Engagement

Apply Now

Sign-up for regular updates from Generocity