Opinion: Budget cuts would make us a city with no front door - Generocity Philly


May 8, 2020 8:33 am

Opinion: Budget cuts would make us a city with no front door

The growth that Philadelphia has experienced in population, in jobs, in reputation, are all a result of the offices the mayor proposes to cut or eliminate, says guest columnist Deborah Diamond.

Campus Philly's February 2020 STEM career event, Wired Philly, at the Franklin Institute.

(Photo by Daoud Moon for Campus Philly)

The new budget proposed by Mayor Kenney demonstrates that the city will function and provide basic services to residents despite dramatic revenue declines due to COVID-19.

But it’s a budget that provides no front door to anyone from outside Philadelphia looking in. What do I mean and why does it matter?

The most dramatic cuts — and I don’t mean in amounts because the amounts are relatively small; I mean in completely eliminating city functions — are in the Commerce Department (gutted by 85% and down to 4 people), the Office of the City Representative (completely eliminated), and the Office of Arts, Culture and the Creative Economy (completely eliminated). These cuts total $12 million out of the $4.9 billion proposed budget.

It is possible that in the coming year most residents in the city of Philadelphia won’t feel the elimination of these departments. But for those on the outside, looking in, they make Philadelphia disappear. These offices are our city’s front door: they are the point of contact for international businesses exploring a U.S. headquarters; they represent Philadelphia on the national and international stage; they create the city-wide spectacles and celebrations that are televised nationally and are what the world knows us for.  And, they also represent the elimination of our City’s welcome to tens of thousands of college students from across the world, because Campus Philly’s funding is contained in those cuts.

I use the “front door” metaphor all the time when talking about Campus Philly. When a new business is thinking of locating in Philadelphia; when an arts organization has a world premiere; when a get-out-the-vote initiative is activated they all seek a way of engaging college students and they come to Campus Philly, grateful that there is a single point of contact to reach 100,000+ college students on more than 50 campuses.

Why does a city having a front door matter and why does it matter in Philadelphia’s case in particular? We’re a World Heritage city with no global image. We’re a college town with a reputation for brain drain (it’s not true). We’re an arts mecca known mostly for sports. The Commerce Department, the Office of Arts, Culture and the Creative Economy and the Office of the City Representative are our city’s rebuttal. And, they’ve been remarkably successful. The growth that Philadelphia has experienced in population, in jobs, in reputation (the NFL Draft; the Pope’s visit; the DNC; top placement in the Amazon HQ2 bid) are all a result of these offices.

From our Partners

In fact, the reason that day to day life in Philadelphia is not going to change too much next year for most Philadelphians — your trash will get picked up; your library will stay open; you’ll take your kids to the local rec center  — is because these offices that open Philadelphia up to the outside world and bring that outside world in have done such a good job growing our economy. When you lock that front door, who’s going to come in? Where will growth come from?

The economic case for these offices is paramount now. But as a third-generation Philadelphian who has also lived in other large US cities and abroad, these offices represent something more significant. They represent the difference between a provincial, inward looking, narrow city and a cosmopolitan, world-renowned, outward looking city.

So this is my plea: don’t cut basic services, but find $12 million to open Philadelphia to the world again.


From our Partners

5 fun ways Philly orgs have pivoted to virtual

Memorial Day: 8 ways veterans are particularly vulnerable to the coronavirus

There’s a grant for that: 6 opportunities available from late May to mid-June, and on a rolling basis


Generocity Philly

¿Cómo preparamos a estudiantes sin ninguna historia familiar de educación universitaria?

Philadelphia, PA

Episcopal Community Services

Digital Marketing Manager

Apply Now
Philadelphia (currently remote)

Big Brothers Big Sisters Independence

Human Resources Director

Apply Now

Urban Technology Project

AmeriCorps Digital Service Fellow

Apply Now

Controller Rebecca Rhynhart releases analysis of proposed 2021 budget, and offers an alternative

Opinion: Adult education isn’t a priority in the FY21 budget — but it should be

Research brief: New tool to measure gender bias in the workplace may help finally eliminate it


Generocity Philly

How do we prepare first-generation graduates for college?


Heifer International

Director of Philanthropy, Mid-Atlantic Region

Apply Now

Public Health Management Corporation

Special Education Teacher

Apply Now

Public Health Management Corporation


Apply Now

Sign-up for daily news updates from Generocity